15 Best Mexican Restaurants in Fort Collins, CO

Quesadillas, tacos, and enchiladas are lip-smackingly delicious Mexican staples of all time! They are perfect as a quick meal or appetizer for a Mexican party. If you’re craving these types of food but don’t know where to order yet, don’t fret. We have the best Mexican restaurants in Fort Collins, CO, for you!

Blue Agave Grill

$$ | (970) 631-8076 | Website


View this post on Instagram


A post shared by Blue Agave Grill (@blueagavegrillcolorado)

Are you looking for a Mexican Restaurant in Colorado to celebrate a big party? Check out Blue Agave Grill, one of the best Mexican restaurants in Fort Collins. This place takes pride in providing guests with top-notch dishes and bringing out the best when it comes to customer service.

Blue Agave Grill opened its doors to the public in 2014. Since then, they have been giving top-notch Mexican specials, like mango fish tacos, enchiladas, and Relleno that guests love and enjoy.

They also cater to parties and huge events! If you’re planning to have a Mexican party, don’t hesitate to book catering with this fine place.


Taqueria Los Comales

$$ | (970) 407-9998 | Website


View this post on Instagram


A post shared by Los Comales TMT (@loscomalesfortcollins)

Taqueria Los Comales is a restaurant in Fort Collins that serves authentic Mexican food. Since 2001, this Mexican food place has been bringing the best and freshest meals to its diners’ tables. Whether you’re craving sizzling tacos or smothered burritos, there’s something for you at Taqueria Los Comales.

This Mexican restaurant has special offers, like the El Portillo, which consists of a meat of your choice, rice and beans, tortillas, and salad. They also have Platillo de tamales, served with rice and beans.

Another meal you can try is their Tostada special with shredded beef or chicken, with rice, beans, sour cream, tomato, lettuce, and guacamole on the side. At Taqueria Los Comales, you’re sure to get the most delicious Mexican meals made with the highest quality ingredients!


Tortilla Marissa’s

$$ | (970) 225-9222 | Website

Tortilla Marissa's

Tortilla Marissa’s is another Mexican Restaurant in Colorado’s Fort Collins. This place has been serving the city with the best Mexican staples for more than 30 years!

All sauces and chips made at Tortilla Marissa’s are made fresh daily. They use no artificial ingredients, so they ensure you get the most nutrients from their top-notch menu items.

Tortilla Marissa’s has a menu filled with exciting staples from Texas, New Mexico, Arizona, Colorado, and California. Their options include quesadillas, soups, and fajitas. They also have special menu items in-store!

The overall vibe of this restaurant is vibrant, colorful, and soothing. The ambiance makes the place a great spot to hang out with your friends and family.


Cafe Mexicali

$$ | (970) 266-9292 | Website

Cafe Mexical

Next on our list of the best Mexican restaurants in Fort Collins, is Cafe Mexicali. This place is an excellent location to get the freshest Mexican meals you are craving. Cafe Mexicali has your favorite Mexican food, and they ensure its freshness and deliciousness!

Cafe Mexicali has dishes for all. They have enchiladas, salads, soups, burritos, tacos, and nachos. They also have gluten-free, dairy-free, and vegetarian options.

With their tagline, “as fresh as it gets,” you’re assured to get the finest and freshest Mexican meals in this spot. With over 15 years of excellent service, you can never go wrong with dining in this place. It truly deserves to be on top!


Pueblo Viejo

$$ | (970) 221-1170 | Website

Pueblo Viejo

Dine in at Pueblo Viejo Mexican Restaurant and be surprised by the flavors and flares of Mexico. This spot brings authentic and classic Mexican dishes to Fort Collins. Guests love the vibe of this place—they say Pueblo Viejo is a fantastic starter of the night.

Pueblo Viejo guarantees all its menu items are served to perfection. They have delicious dishes like the Pueblo Viejo Combo, Taco Salad Cazuela, and spinach quesadilla. They also have lovely margaritas.

Pueblo Viejo also caters to big events and parties. Make your day extra special by booking this lovely Mexican restaurant!


Hacienda Real

$$ | (970) 221-2535 | Website


View this post on Instagram


A post shared by Hacienda Real (@haciendarealmexicanrestaurant)

If you’re searching for the perfect place to grab drinks and mingle with your friends and family, check out Hacienda Real. Hacienda Real is a family Mexican restaurant that serves tasty dishes, refreshing margaritas, cold beer, and Michelada.

Hacienda Real Family Restaurant has been in service for over 15 years. This family-owned and operated place takes pride in offering tasty and unmatched Mexican cuisine. They have a lunch menu, seafood meals, burritos, meats, fajitas, and many more.

All their staff is friendly, skilled, and helpful, so you know you’ll get the best service. Check them out to know more!


La Buena Vida

$$ | (970) 631-8186 | Website

La Buena Vida

Are you looking for an award-winning Mexican restaurant? Here’s La Buena Vida, one of the best Mexican restaurants in Fort Collins.

La Buena Vida is a Mexican cuisine and margarita bar. This place has weekly and daily specials for a unique dining experience each time you book a seat in this lovely place.

La Buena Vida has enchilada morelia, chile rellenos, ensaladas, postres, and more. They have dinner combinations, too. What’s great is that their menu items are award-winning and hand-cooked! La Buena Vida is open daily, so if you’re looking for an accessible place, check out this restaurant.


Rio Grande

$$ | (970) 224-5428  | Website


View this post on Instagram


A post shared by Rio Grande Mexican Restaurants (@myriogrande)

Since 1986, Rio Grande has been delivering Colorado excellent Mexican dishes. It started when McGaughran, Rio Grande’s owner and founder, strived to learn about a new and different cuisine: Mexican. He loved everything about Mexican cuisine as they spent time in the country.

Rio Grande Mexican Restaurant is home to delicious margaritas, tasty fajitas, and black beans. They ensure that all diners get the best and most timeless Mexican staples. Included in Rio Grande’s menu are Patron Patio Smash Cocktails, mocktails, quesadillas, enchiladas, and tostadas.

Rio Grande has hand-picked tequila options too. This place’s meals and drinks prove why they’re one of the top choices!


Inca Mexican Restaurant

$$ | (970) 484-3400 | Website

Inca Mexican Restaurant

If you haven’t found the perfect Mexican food place to dine in yet, try Inca Mexican Restaurant. This restaurant is a spot to get the most superb and yummy recipes from Jalisco, Mexico.

Inca has a nice vibe to meet with your friends and family. You can find the tastiest Mexican classics that can be your next favorite food!

Inca ensures all meals are made with the freshest ingredients from scratch. Through this, they are able to deliver the real flavors and flares of Mexico, giving you a unique dining experience you won’t forget. Inca has four convenient locations in the US.


Los Tarascos Restaurant

$$ | (970) 416-0265 | Website


View this post on Instagram


A post shared by Los Tarascos (@lostarascosco)

Calling all taco and margarita fans! Here’s a Mexican restaurant for you: Los Tarascos Restaurant. This place is a family-owned and operated food spot since 1995.

It was founded by husband and wife Hugo and Maria Caballero. Their love and passion for cooking have emerged into a fantastic restaurant serving the dining scene of Fort Collins for over 20 years now.

Los Tarascos is the place to get refreshing margaritas made with Lunazul Reposado served in a cocktail glass with salt and ice. They also have an array of beers and Michelada. Their dinner menu consists of various aperitivos, enchiladas, mariscos, rellenos, burritos, and tacos.


Matador Mexican Grill

$ | (970) 372-5876 | Website


View this post on Instagram


A post shared by Matador Mexican Grill (@matadormexicangrill)

Another award-winning Mexican restaurant on our list is Matador Mexican Grill. This place has been regarded as a restaurant to get the best Mexican food, tacos, and breakfast burritos in Fort Collins. They are open for dine-in guests and online orders.

Matador Mexican Grill has smothered burritos, served with chile, pablanlo sauce or enchilada sauce.They have tacos, sopapillas, churros, salads, and more.

They also have beers in-store offered at the best price! If you love good food, fun vibes, and a cozy, lively ambiance, then Matador Mexican Grill is the place to be.


Las 4 Americas

$ | (970) 221-4017 | Website

Las 4 Americas

Las 4 Americas is a top local choice when looking for a tortilleria, taqueria, and abarrotes. This place is a one-stop restaurant for your favorite Mexican classics! Plus, they are sold at a very reasonable price. You can have these for huge events, like birthday parties and family gatherings.

This restaurant has burritos, tacos, platillos, caldos, and more. They have a whole list of tasty Mexican delicacies and classic menu items. Las 4 Americas has two locations in Colorado – one in Fort Collins and the other in Evans.


Cafe Rio Mexican Grill

$ | (970) 530-2700 | Website

Cafe Rio Mexican Grill

Cafe Rio Mexican Grill has chef-inspired classics and scratch-made masterpieces in-store to satisfy your craving. They guarantee the use of fresh ingredients daily, with surprising flavors to burst in your mouth.

Whether you’re planning a simple hangout with friends or having a special occasion, Cafe Rio can cater to your needs! They have buffet-style and packed meal options you can choose from to have in your next event.

Cafe Rio is home to authentic sweet pork barbacoa. This signature dish is a favorite of locals and tourists alike. This original recipe is delightful and flavorful. Be sure to try Cafe Rio’s pork barbacoa when you visit!


Illegal Pete’s

$ | (970) 999-3051 | Website

Illegal Pete's

Looking for a quick place to eat your favorite burrito? Illegal Pete’s is here! This Mexican restaurant offers the classic Pete experience with its bowls, salads, and burritos. Every day, you can try different burrito combos to get a unique dining moment every time!

Illegal Pete’s has various specialties, like the quesadilla, taquitos, and vegan green chile bowl. As you can see, there is something for everyone in this Mexican restaurant. If you’re a lover of chips and dips, they are also available every day in two sizes.

You can also choose sides to pair with your meal. Illegal Pete’s indeed has lots of menu items in-store. So, why not try this place out?


La Luz

$$ | (970) 267-9444 | Website

La Luz

La Luz Mexican Grill is perfect for diners who love fresh, raw ingredients sourced locally. La Luz’s menu items are made from scratch daily. They have seafood, vegetables, and meals served with Mexican spices, flavored in citrusy juices, and grilled to perfection and freshness.

La Luz Mexican Grill also has a salsa bar that has gained many awards and accolades. They have mild corn salsa and fiery chipotle salsa, with vegan and vegetarian options. If you’re bringing kids with you, the good news is they can eat free every Sunday!

For parties and events, La Luz can also cater to your needs. They can accommodate baby showers, birthdays, graduation celebrations, rehearsal dinners, and more.


Final Thoughts

When planning a simple dinner with friends or hosting a Mexican party in Colorado, you won’t run out of good Mexican restaurants.

These restaurants are ready to surprise your taste buds with their tasty menu items. The next time you crave a quesadilla, you know where to go—thanks to our list of the best restaurants in Fort Collins, CO!

Choose your favorite restaurant (up to 3)

Mexican Restaurants in Fort Collins, CO

Leave a Comment

About Restaurant Observer

Restaurant Observer is the ultimate go-to destination on the web when looking for nothing but fantastic places to genuinely enjoy food across the United States. Inspired by the saying when there’s good food, there’s a good life, Birch Restaurant starts the food blog to scout the best food places across the country.