We’ve put together a list of the best restaurants in Payson, Arizona, so you can enjoy a great meal no matter what your budget or taste buds may be.
Whether you’re looking for a casual dining experience or a more upscale option, there’s sure to be something on this list that will suit your needs. You can rest assured that you’ll be getting a good meal at a reasonable price no matter where you choose to eat.
$$ | (928) 474-7411 | WEBSITE
If you’re looking for a great casual dining option in Payson, AZ, Macky’s Grill is a great choice. The menu features a wide variety of American classics, including burgers, sandwiches, salads, and more. The prices are very reasonable, and the quality of the food is excellent.
The service is also friendly and efficient. It’s perfect for dog owners as Macky’s is a dog-friendly restaurant with a large patio area where your furry friend can enjoy their meal with you.
$$ | (928) 474-7455 | WEBSITE
If you’re looking for a delicious steak dinner in Payson, AZ, look no further than Fargo’s Steakhouse. The menu features a variety of steak options, all of which are cooked to perfection. The sides are also top-notch, and the service is wonderful.
Whether you’re in the mood for a romantic evening out or a night out with friends, Fargo’s Steakhouse is the place to be. The warm atmosphere and attentive staff will make you feel right at home.
Buffalo Bar and Grill
$$ | (928) 474-3900 | WEBSITE
This restaurant is known for its delicious buffalo-style wings, which were voted Best In Town in 2021. In addition to their wings, they also serve some great burgers and sandwiches.
The atmosphere is casual and relaxed, making it a great place to enjoy a meal with friends. The service is friendly and efficient, and the prices are reasonable. This country-style pub is a must if you’re out and about in Payson.
Rim Country BBQ
$$ | (928) 472-2227 | WEBSITE
View this post on Instagram
Rim Country BBQ is located in a prime spot on historic Main Street. They serve up barbecue favorites like pulled pork, ribs, and chicken from a handcrafted menu. The sides are also fantastic, with options like baked beans, coleslaw, and potato salad.
This family-friendly, dog-friendly restaurant is always packed, and for good reason- the food is incredible! Don’t miss the best barbecue in Arizona when you’re in Payson.
$$ | (928) 474-3111 | WEBSITE
El Rancho is a Mexican restaurant located in Payson, Arizona. The family-owned and operated business has been serving up authentic Mexican food for over 20 years. The menu features all of your favorite dishes, like enchiladas, tacos, burritos, and more.
The portions are large and the prices are reasonable. El Rancho is the perfect place to go for a delicious and affordable meal. The low-key environment makes it a perfect casual dining option.
Tiny’s Family Restaurant and Lounge
$ | (928) 474-5429 | WEBSITE
If you’re ever in Payson and are looking for a great place to eat, be sure to check out Tiny’s Family Restaurant and Lounge. This local favorite serves up some of the best American cuisines in town.
The restaurant itself has a cozy, homey atmosphere that makes it the perfect place to grab a bite. The simple diner serves favorite dishes like meatloaf and pancakes at low prices, all day long. They even stay open to serve meals on Thanksgiving Day! Tiny’s is the quintessential family restaurant, and you’re sure to feel right at home here.
Ayothaya Thai Cafe
$$ | (928) 474-1112 | WEBSITE
Ayothaya Thai Cafe brings together culture and comfort with its delicious food and warm atmosphere. From their Pad Thai to their green curry chicken, every dish is packed with authentic Thai flavors that will leave your taste buds tingling.
And if you’re looking for a truly unique experience, be sure to try their Thai iced tea – it’s made with fresh Thai herbs and spices and served in a traditional clay pot. Ayothaya is a wonderful restaurant for expanding your taste buds and enjoying authentic Thai food in the heart of Payson.
$$ | (928) 363-4011 | WEBSITE
Duza’s Kitchen is a standout eatery with a spin on traditional American dishes such as a full breakfast platter, lamb, and short rib. They also push the limits of flavor by branching out into other cuisines.
Duza’s takes anything that’s already been done and brings you a better version of it. For example, their short rib is slow-cooked for hours to perfection and served with a flavorful Korean gochujang glaze. If you’re looking for an innovative and delicious dining experience, Duza’s Kitchen is the place for you.
La Sierra Mexican Restaurant
$$ | (928) 428-6711 | WEBSITE
La Sierra Mexican Restaurant is one of the best places in Payson to get your fix of authentic Mexican cuisine. Their menu features all of your favorite dishes, such as enchiladas, tacos, and quesadillas – but they also have a few unique offerings like their grilled vegetable burrito.
And if you’re looking for something truly special, be sure to try their handmade corn tortillas – they’re made fresh daily and are absolutely delicious. Whether you’re in the mood for a quick bite or a leisurely meal, La Sierra is sure to please.
The Oxbow Saloon and Grill
$$ | (928) 474-4261 | WEBSITE
If you’re looking for a taste of the Old West, look no further than The Oxbow Saloon & Grill in Payson, Arizona. This historic spot has been serving up some of the best food in town since 1884. Their restaurant features barbecue, burgers, and delicious sides.
Themed dinner parties are often hosted in the Oxbow Saloon, making this bar and grill as eclectic as it is true to its Arizona roots. There is also an inn attached to the Oxbow Saloon, so you can stay the night if you’re looking for a true cowboy experience.
$ | (928) 474-1613 | WEBSITE
Crosswinds Restaurant is a unique, aviation-themed restaurant located in Payson, AZ. The menu features a variety of American and Southwest cuisine, including burgers, wings, sandwiches, salads, and more.
The restaurant also has a full bar with a wide selection of beers, wines, and spirits. Crosswinds is the perfect place to enjoy a meal with family or friends while coming into or leaving Payson. The one-of-a-kind restaurant is in the airport itself, making Crosswinds the perfect place for your first or last meal in Payson.
Backwoods Bar and Grill
$$ | (928) 474-6883 | WEBSITE
View this post on Instagram
Backwoods Bar and Grill prides itself on being a local restaurant with a great atmosphere and delicious food. The menu features American classics with a twist, such as the Backwoods Philly cheesesteak sandwich served with green chilies, onion, and mushrooms.
The bar has a wide selection of beers, wines, and spirits, making it the perfect place to relax after a long day. It’s also a wonderful place to come on game day with several TVs around the bar. Family-friendly and a local favorite, Backwoods is a great place for both locals and visitors to Payson, AZ.
El Rodeo Mexican Restaurant and Cantina
$ | (928) 474-3328 | WEBSITE
If you’re looking for some authentic Mexican food in Payson, AZ, be sure to check out El Rodeo Mexican Restaurant and Cantina. This family-owned restaurant serves up traditional dishes like enchiladas, tamales, and tacos, as well as more unique items like the chile verde burrito.
The portions are generous and the prices are very reasonable, making El Rodeo a great option for budget-minded diners. And if you’re looking to drink something other than soda with your meal, the restaurant has a full bar with a nice selection of beers, wines, and spirits.
$ | (928) 474-2890 | WEBSITE
Pinon Cafe is the home of the best breakfast in Rim Country and is known for its southern-style food. The restaurant is currently run by a husband and wife team who are passionate about their quality food. The menu features classic southern dishes like biscuits and gravy, fried chicken, and catfish.
The cafe also has a full bar with a wide selection of beer and wine. The Pinon Cafe was the first restaurant in Arizona and has been owned and operated by local families since it was opened. For a slice of history, make sure to stop by the Pinon Cafe.
The best restaurants in Payson can be found on this list. No matter what your taste, there’s something for everyone in Payson.
From southern comfort food to fresh seafood, there’s a restaurant on this list that will tantalize your taste buds. So, the next time you’re in Payson, make sure to check out one (or all!) of these 14 amazing restaurants. You won’t be disappointed.
Hayden has been a digital director for years. He has five years of experience editing and writing about food, restaurant, and recipe review content. At Birch Restaurant, he’s in charge of scouting, showing up unannounced in different restaurants, and writing a thorough food guide!